Lash artists have been asking us for premade fans for years.
And for years, my answer was the same: not yet.
Not because I'm a premade snob — I've never been against them. But because every time I tested a tray, something didn't sit right, and I wasn't willing to put our name on a product I wouldn't use on my own clients. That delay cost us sales. I'd make the same decision again.
Here's the honest story of why we waited, what I kept finding, and what finally changed my mind.
First, I Assumed It Was Me
I've been lashing since 2014. I test everything that comes through our doors, because I don't believe you can sell a product you haven't lived with.
So I tested premade fans. Lots of them — different suppliers, different brands, different price points, over a long stretch of time.
And set after set, something was off. Retention wasn't what it should have been. The attachment never felt right under the tweezer.
My first instinct wasn't to blame the product. It was to ask the question every honest artist asks first: is it me? Am I missing something? Is there a technique everyone else has cracked that I haven't? I changed my placement. I changed my adhesive. I changed my dip depth. I went back to basics on isolation.
I still wasn't convinced.
And eventually, after enough trays from enough brands, a pattern is a pattern — not a skill gap.
What I Kept Finding
Two things came up again and again.
The fibres felt plasticky. Not every brand, but far too many. There's a particular stiffness you can feel the moment you pick a fan up — it doesn't move like a lash should, it doesn't sit against the natural lash the way a handmade fan does, and you can see it in the finished set if you know what you're looking for.
And they were pre-bonded. This, I think, is the real culprit. Those fans are held together at the base before they ever reach your tray — and that bonded base is where everything went wrong for me. The fans were constantly brushing off. I never got proper contact between the extension and the natural lash; whatever I did, the connection just wasn't there the way it is with a handmade fan. However careful my application was, I was building sets on a foundation I didn't trust.
And before anyone asks — yes, I tried the ones that are supposed to solve this.
The glued bases were the most obvious offender. You can see the adhesive sitting there, holding several separate fibres together, and you can feel the stiffness it leaves behind.
The pointy bases were the ones I had most hope for. That's the whole promise, isn't it — a fine, tapered base that's meant to slip neatly against the natural lash and bond like a handmade fan. On paper it's the right idea. In my hands it still wasn't making proper contact, and I was still brushing fans off at the end of a set.
The heat-bonded ones too — marketed as the clean alternative because there's no adhesive involved in holding the fan together. Better in principle. Same outcome for me.
Different brands, different base styles, different claims — and I kept ending up in the same place. That's what eventually convinced me the issue wasn't one bad batch or one bad supplier. Anything bonded at the base, however it was bonded and however finely it was tapered, just didn't behave the way I needed it to on the natural lash.
That's the thing about premade fan debates online — everyone argues about speed versus artistry, and almost nobody talks about the base. For me, the base was the whole story.
The Part Nobody Talks About: The Maths
There was a business objection too, and it mattered just as much.
Premade trays are expensive — and what you get for the money is limited. A tray in one dimension, one length, one curl. For a lash artist actually building bespoke sets, that's a narrow window of usefulness for a significant chunk of your supplies budget. You end up buying several trays to cover one client, and most of what you've paid for sits unused.
I couldn't look our artists in the eye and tell them that was good value. Our customers are working professionals with real margins to protect — I'm not going to sell them a product that quietly eats into them.
Then I Found Narrow W Lashes
I kept looking. Not for a cheaper premade fan — for a different answer entirely.
And eventually I found narrow W lashes.
The construction is completely different. Traditional premades glue separate fibres together into a bundle. A W lash isn't glued at all — the fibres are rolled into one at the base. It's a manufacturing technique, not an adhesive one, and that single detail changes everything: no bonded bundle, no factory glue, no bulk. Just a slim, unified base carrying the fullness of a fan.
Everything I'd been frustrated by simply wasn't there any more.
A Year of Testing Before I'd Say a Word
I didn't launch them on first impressions. I tested them for about a year — on my own clients, through seasons, through humidity changes, through infill cycles where retention either proves itself or doesn't.
And they did.
They attach beautifully. Proper, full contact between the extension and the natural lash — the connection I'd been missing with every glued-base tray I'd tried.
No brush-offs. This was the big one for me. The constant brushing off that had frustrated me for years simply stopped.
Retention was genuinely excellent. Not "fine for a premade." Excellent, full stop — the kind of retention that holds up at the three-week infill and makes a client ask what you did differently.
I'll be honest about what surprised me most: it opened my mind to the whole category. I went in sceptical, as somebody who had never been convinced premade fans were efficient. I came out thinking this is what premades should always have been.
What We Launched — And What's Coming
That testing became our Bloom Collection.
The 3DW Narrow Pre-Made Volume Fans are the soft, true 3D density set — balanced fans with a clean symmetrical top line and that slim rolled base doing the heavy lifting. 4DW sits alongside them for artists wanting a little more fullness, and 5D is coming soon.
And I want to be clear about why I'm excited rather than just satisfied: this technology is still evolving. I'm hoping manufacturers will keep extending the range — thicker, finer, more options across the W construction — because every step forward here means lash artists can work more efficiently without compromising on quality. That matters. Efficiency isn't a dirty word in this industry; it's how artists protect their hands, fill their columns and make better money doing work they're proud of.
What I'd Say to the Artist Still Unsure
If you've tried premade fans and quietly wondered whether the problem was you — it probably wasn't. Look at the base. That's where most of the retention conversation actually lives, and it's the part the marketing rarely mentions.
And if you've written the whole category off because of a bad experience with heavy, plasticky, pre-bonded trays: I understand completely. I was there for years. The construction has changed, and it's worth another look.
I'm not telling you to stop making fans by hand. My handmade work isn't going anywhere, and neither should yours — bespoke customisation is still an artistry premades can't replicate. But for the body of a set, for consistency across four hundred fans, for the days when your column is full and your hands are tired? This is the tool I wish I'd had years ago.
We were late. We were late on purpose. And I'd rather be the brand that arrives last with something I actually use than first with something I don't.
Explore the Bloom Collection →
Arune Mooney, Founder, I AM Lash PRO ♥️
FAQ
What's the difference between W lashes and premade fans?
Traditional premade fans hold several separate fibres together at the base — with adhesive, with a heat seal, or tapered into a pointy base. W lashes aren't bonded at all: the fibres are rolled into one during manufacture, so there's no bundle to hold together, no base bulk, just a slim unified base carrying fan-like density.
Are pointy or heat-bonded premade fans better than glued ones?
In principle they should be — a finer or adhesive-free base is the right instinct. In our own testing across multiple brands, all three still left us with the same problem: insufficient contact with the natural lash and fans brushing off.
Are W lashes better for retention?
In our testing, significantly. The slim rolled base makes proper contact with the natural lash, which is exactly what we found missing with bonded-base trays of every kind — and it's why the brush-offs stopped.
Why do some premade fans feel stiff or plasticky?
Fibre quality varies enormously between manufacturers, and pre-bonded bases add rigidity. Both affect how the fan behaves against the natural lash and how the finished set looks.
Are premade fans worth the money?
It depends entirely on the construction and how much usable range you get per tray. Our objection to traditional premades was always value as much as performance.
Do W lashes replace handmade fanning?
No — handmade fans still win on bespoke customisation. W lashes are for the body of a set, for consistency and for speed on busy days.
Every product we stock is tested by a working lash artist before it earns a place on our shelves. That's not a slogan — it's why some of our launches take years.